Home / Banking Strategies / Five steps for hiring bankers who can sell

Five steps for hiring bankers who can sell


Recruiting is a big problem for most banks and financial firms. The question is always, “How do I hire bankers who can also sell?” Unfortunately, there is no simple answer to this question. However, the one thing you must recognize is that you and your process are responsible for the quality of the salespeople on your team today. Recruiting and hiring are like sales: you must have an effective system in place. Recruiting is not a “sometime” thing; it is an “all the time activity” for sales leaders.

Here are five initial steps that will help line-of-business sales managers get ready to hire better salespeople (who are also bankers):

Realize and admit that you have people on your team today who are underperforming. That is the norm, but that doesn’t mean that you have to accept it; if you do, then you are part of the problem. Break out of the accepted premise that you cannot possibly have everyone on your team hitting their goal and that you should lower your goals instead. That, unfortunately, is the reality that most companies struggle with. They don’t actually lower the goal; they just accept mediocrity when goals are not hit.

Since 20% to 30% of the people on the team carry the load, get the overall performance to exceed expectations while everyone else gets a free pass. Sure, you have people on the lower end – three standard deviations from the norm – but, typically, those are new hires or producers with large revenue streams who have “retired” but just haven’t told anyone.

Realize that you are perfectly designed for the results you are getting today. Everything you do around recruiting, performance management, coaching, mentoring, on-boarding and training influences your ability to attract, hire and retain better sales people. When you look at the people you have on the team and put them on an 80/20 grid and realize that 33% of your people are generating north of 80% of the results, you can easily see that those others add virtually nothing to the equation when it comes to new business. My question is this: did you hire them that way or did you make them that way?

Decide today that you are going to hire better sales people and not deviate from that objective. Now, be careful about this. This can be like deciding to “get fit.” If you set a goal for exercise and diet that is unreasonable, given your current habits and condition, you end up setting yourself up to fail. So, you have to be strategic about this. Segment your sales group into quintiles, identify the traits and qualities of those top bankers and make sure that, if you are looking to replace someone in the third quintile, your new hire is better than the one you are replacing. According to Brad Smart, author of Topgrading, 75% of new hires are either worse or no better than the person being exited. That is a very painful mistake and you can do better than that.

Put in a process of establishing exactly the right person for the job. In other words, instead of writing a job description, write down what it takes to be successful in the role and what the role is like day to day. Make sure in your job attraction ad that you attempt to disqualify those people that are just looking for a new contract because they are failing where they are today. That’s just the first step. You have to have a process that is followed routinely by everyone involved in the recruiting. Make sure you conduct strong phone interviews and have a pre-hire sales assessment versus just a personality or behavior profile. Such profiles are nice for the manager and might tell if they can sell, but ultimately won’t tell you if they will sell.

Set expectations for new hires. Once you find the exact right person (the perfect fit for the role) and have convinced them that your company is exactly the right place for them to finish their professional sales career, your next step is to … try to discourage them from taking the job. Tell them in precise detail exactly what is expected: how they will be managed, that the pressure to succeed is going to be high, that they will fill out activity reports, that they must keep their pipeline/CRM up to date, that there will be a huddle every week, that they will not be excused from sales training or sales meetings and that you will meet with them monthly to review the status of their success and lay out their career path for them. Give them plenty of reasons to reconsider. And oh, by the way, make sure that when you make your offer, they are ready to tell you yes or no.

Now, there is a bonus step that trumps all five of the above for hiring better sales people and here it is: implement a system and execute on it consistently. 

Mr. Cole is president of Cincinnati, Ohio-based Anthony Cole Training Group, LLC. He can be reached at [email protected].